Health Department Closes Charlotte Abortion Clinic Posing Danger to the Public

Charlotte, North Carolina – A Preferred Women’s Health Center (PWHC), a troubled abortion clinic in Charlotte, North Carolina, has been ordered to close by the North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services after failing a second inspection in four months and posing a threat to public health.

The Division of Health Service Regulation (DHSR) summarily suspended PWHC’s certificate to operate based on an inspection conducted in response to a complaint. The DHSR’s finding stated:

This Summary Suspension is based on this agency’s findings that conditions at A Preferred Women’s Health Center, LLC, present an imminent danger to the health, safety and welfare of the clients and that emergency action is required to protect the clients.

According to an inspection report conducted on April 20, 2013, the clinic was found to be improperly dispensing an abortion drug, Methotrexate, in a dangerous manner contrary to manufacturer’s specifications. The clinic was dispensing the intravenous version of the drug to women orally, causing failed abortions that necessitated surgery.

Methotrexate is a drug developed to treat cancer, but has been used to induce abortions after it was discovered that early abortion was a side effect of the drug. It is usually used in conjunction with Cytotec to induce contractions, but there is no notation in the DHSR’s deficiency report to indicate whether Cytotec was used.

The inspector interviewed the abortionist who inexcusably denied responsibility for the administration of the drugs he prescribes. The report stated:

The physician stated that he had worked at the clinic 14 years and until two years ago, the clinic gave Methotrexate intramuscular. The physician stated around two years ago the administration decided to begin giving the Methotrexate injectable orally. The physician stated “I don’t order (the medication). The clinic decides. I just sign. Oral or Injectable is not indicated on the order. The nurse and clinic are independent from me. I leave it to the clinic to decide. I have never seen the (Methotrexate) pill used here.”

“This statement shows an appalling disregard for the health and safety of women that simply cannot be fixed. The abortionist who shirked his responsibility to his patients in such an egregious way that he should not be allowed to practice,” said Newman. “In fact, a clinic that cares so little for patients that they would endanger them repeatedly will never change no matter how many opportunities it is given. You can’t force someone to care about something. The only option is closure, for the good of the public.”

Operation Rescue worked with local activists that filed complaints against PWHC late last year, prompting an inspection in December that resulted in citations for filthy conditions and a lack of emergency protocols were discovered. The clinic had been the site of multiple botched abortion emergencies, also reported by Operation Rescue.

The two abortionists employed by PWHC are Stuart Lee Schnider and Ron Virmani. Both have troubled backgrounds. Schnider was sued in 2002 after botching an abortion that resulted in a total hysterectomy. Virmani attained notoriety as a racist last year after telling pro-life activists that he aborted “those ugly black babies” because he did not want his tax dollars going to support them.

“PWHC operates a second location in Raliegh that must be immediately inspected. There’s no reason to believe that the Raleigh site is any better than their shoddy Charlotte location. These people have been proved to pose a danger to the public. We encourage folks to contact the Separtment of Health and demand an immediate and unannounced inspection of Preferred Women’s Health Clinic in Raleigh,” said Newman.

Please contact:

North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services
Division of Health Service Regulation
Complaint Intake Unit
Voice: 919-855-4500
E-Mail: dhsr.webmaster@dhhs.nc.gov

911 Recordings Reveal 3 Planned Parenthood Patients Suffering Serious Abortion Complications


Orange, CA — Operation Rescue has obtained recordings and Computer Aided Dispatch Transcripts for four 911 calls placed from a single Planned Parenthood in Orange, California, three of which were made on the same day seeking emergency transport for patients suffering complications from an abortion and one employee experiencing from chest pain.

The records raise additional questions concerning patient safety of Planned Parenthood and other abortion clinics across the nation. Operation Rescue has documented 22 medical emergencies occurring at abortion clinics nationwide since January 1, 2013. This includes five medical emergencies at a Planned Parenthood in Wilmington, Delaware, which later fired its abortionist and closed down for “cleaning” after public outcry erupted.

“There simply is no such thing as a ‘safe and legal’ abortion clinic,” said Troy Newman, President of Operation Rescue and Pro-Life Nation. “Women are injured or killed, and babies die as a matter of course in our nation’s abortion clinics and we have yet to find one that obeys the law on all points. Health and safety violations are rampant at abortion clinics, and Planned Parenthood is certainly no exception.”

The records show that on February 22, 2013, three calls to 911 for emergency help were placed from a Planned Parenthood surgical abortion clinic located at 700 S. Tustin St. in Orange, California.

The first of the three calls that day was placed at 7:28 am reporting that a 44-year old employee was suffering from angina and chest pain. Her color was turning pale. A nurse was present, but no doctor was on the scene. She was transported to the hospital at 8:09 am.

The second call was placed at 12:31 pm indicating that a 34-year old patient was suffering from seizures and convulsions. She had fallen out of a wheelchair and was “foaming through the mouth” according to the Planned Parenthood employee who placed the call. The ambulance was cancelled by abortionist John Paul McHugh, who told the emergency dispatcher that they would hold on to the patient and observe her condition.

At 6:00 pm, a third call was placed from the same Planned Parenthood abortion clinic. By this time, the dispatcher readily recognized the address as belonging to Planned Parenthood.

The caller reported a medical emergency with another 34-year old patient, who possibly could have been the same patient who suffered the seizures earlier in the day. This time, the reported condition was hemorrhage and lacerations. The patient suffered an altered state of consciousness, according to poorly redacted CAD transcripts, was alert on and off, and was experiencing abnormal breathing. Her blood pressure was dropping and Planned Parenthood workers were starting to administer oxygen. Emergency workers transported her to the hospital emergency room at 6:24 pm.

“It appears that the abortionist on duty, John McHugh, was having a very bad day,” said Troy Newman, President of Operation Rescue and Pro-Life Nation. “From the descriptions on the record, this last patient was very close to bleeding out from some kind of laceration inflicted on her during her abortion.”

But that was far from the end of Planned Parenthood’s problems.

On March 9, 2013, at 3:34 pm, a Planned Parenthood employee placed a call to 911 seeking transport to University of California-Irvine hospital emergency room for a 26-year old second trimester abortion patient suffering from hemorrhage and lacerations. The patient was transported to the hospital at 3:59 pm.

Second trimester abortions are usually 2-3 day procedures and involves the dismemberment of the baby. Laceration and hemorrhage are common complications from this abortion process, which is done blindly by the abortionist and involves grasping and pulling motions that require force due to the advanced development of the baby.

Operation Rescue has documented four other medical emergencies at the Planned Parenthood in Orange. Those incidents took place on February 18, 2013, and September 16 and 29, 2009.

“Planned Parenthood needs to close this dangerous abortion mill down,” said Newman. “They pretend to care about women, but their actions — including a steady stream of ambulances rushing patients to the emergency room — speak louder than words.”

Please contact the Orange County Health Department and demand an immediate site inspection of Planned Parenthood located at 700 Tustin Ave., Orange, CA.

Orange County Health Department Site Mitigation:
Voice: 714-433-6262
E-Mail: ssundaram@ochca.com

UPDATE: The e-mail recipient above is referring people to the following link where they can file a formal complaint: https://hfcis.cdph.ca.gov/LongTermCare/ConsumerComplaint.aspx. Please feel free to do so. You do not have to have direct knowledge to file a complaint.

View Planned Parenthood of Orange’s profile page at AbortionDocs.org to view the CAD transcripts.

Competency of Planned Parenthood’s Training Program Questioned After Rash of Botched Abortions

Wilmington, Delaware – The Planned Parenthood abortion clinic that has experienced four botched abortion emergencies in less than five weeks and where a pro-life grandmother was attacked earlier this week, is recruiting medical students for abortion training.

“It is appalling to think that abortionists at this Planned Parenthood with the recent rash of medical emergencies would be teaching others to do abortions that they don’t seem competent to do themselves,” said Troy Newman, President of Operation Rescue and Pro-Life Nation.

The Planned Parenthood training program is seeking first through fourth year medical students and residents, who must absorb the cost of program participation themselves. The advertisement for their program, which appears on the Association of Reproductive Health Professionals web site, indicates that the troubled Wilmington abortion clinic trains 15 new abortionists per year.

“Given the recent safety concerns at this Planned Parenthood facility, it is shocking to think of the shoddy training that must be going on there. We don’t need more abortionists out there maiming women with substandard practices,” said Newman.

Applicants are urged to contact Dr. Eric Schaff, a Planned Parenthood abortionist who has a history of disciplinary action. In August, 2005, Schaff was issued a reprimand and ordered to pay $5,000 for falsifying medical records in New York. Since his discipline there, Schaff has moved on to ply is grisly trade in Delaware and Pennsylvania. Schaff is an outspoken advocate of abortions and feels “empowered” by doing them.

Botched abortions so far this year at the Wilmington Planned Parenthood where Schaff works include:

February 8: Records of the 911 call reveals that a patient suffered respiratory distress and had to be bagged to keep her from dying. She required emergency transport to a hospital emergency room. (View Video)

February 16: 911 records indicate that a patient suffered heavy, uncontrolled bleeding requiring emergency transport to a hospital emergency room. (View Video)

March 8: A patient suffered an incomplete abortion that required hospitalization and emergency surgery five days later. Fetal parts were detected that included a recognizable leg and foot.

March 13: A patient, covered in blankets and sheets from head to toe, was transported by ambulance to a local hospital while a pro-life sidewalk counselor was attacked for attempting to document the incident. It is unknown if the patient survived.

“This clinic needs to be closed in the interest of public safety, and we are in the process of filing complaints to make sure that happen,” said Newman.